Digital Edition

Did you read today's front page stories & breaking news?
Most Read This Week By Jeremy Geelan Reads: 42,757 | By Cloud News Desk Reads: 9,457 | By Cloud News Desk Reads: 8,622 | By Kevin Hoffman Reads: 7,487 | By Gwen Morton; Ted Alford Reads: 6,995 | By Maureen O'Gara Reads: 6,690 | By Jeremy Geelan Reads: 4,761 | By Cloud News Desk Reads: 4,468 | By Jeremy Geelan Reads: 3,864 | By Fuat Kircaali Reads: 3,410 |
|
i-Technology News What's This With Non-GAAP Numbers?
Is the Bubble Mentality Back?
Jul. 31, 2005 02:00 PM
The good times are coming back, sort of. Although employment remains far below its late 90s peak in Silicon Valley, and through the miracle of modern-day offshore outsourcing appears not to be fully recovering soon, the technology industry as a whole is doing much better than it did during the catastrophic first years of the new millenium. Interest rates remain low, providing relatively easy cash for those brave enough to borrow it.
The vast amounts of technology developed adn deployed in the late 90s, in preperation for a Y2K crisis that didn't come (either because it was never a threat or because everyone prepared for it very well), is now at or past the end of its normal replacement/update cycle. And innovation marches on, with things such as web services, wireless techniques, open-source development, and the dawn of the age of ubiquitous computing continuing to the make the technology industry the most dynamic place to be.
Revenue and profitibility numbers for tech companies reflect the industry's minor renaissance. Heavyweights such as Intel, IBM, Cisco, and even HP have shown strength in recent quarters. Emerging industry heavyweights Google and Yahoo continue to grow rapidly, and in a development reminiscent of the late 90s, get punished if their hypergrowth is simply not hyper enough.
Which leads to the topic of this essay: what is it with all this non-GAAP reporting? GAAP, as all financial people and most technical people know, is the agreed-upon set of principles that public companies must follow in reporting their results. GAAP takes two primary ideas--that revenue and expenses should be recorded when a product is delivered or service is sold and that specific expenses should be matched against specific revenues--and lays down a complex set of rules for how money should be treated.
Many executives don't like GAAP, of course. GAAP gives those damnable beancounters too much power, it doesn't recognize the future value of new contracts, it doesn't recognize the "true" value of many assets, and most important, it often doesn't come near expressing the state of a company's cash position.
So back in the go-go 90s, many companies simply stopped reporting it. Oh, they might have stuck GAAP numbers in a footnote somewhere, but what they really wanted to tell the world as their story about their "pro-forma" results, which often did not include pesky things such as accounting for recent acquisitions (especially if they were proving to be bad acquisitions), the cost of short-term money the company had to borrow, or even an accurate accounting of those recent Super Bowl ads.
Pro-forma reporting was the road to perdition, and it played an important role in the vast over-valuing of dot.com companies and even large technology companies in the late 90s. Pro-forma reporting was whatever the company wanted it to be. Pro-forma reporting ignored the fundamental fact that GAAP reporting has been agreed upon by financial people throughout the U.S. and provides an apples-to-apples method for investors to evaluate companies. Deviating from the principles one notch unlevels the playing field for investors, and it is investors that fund any company's business.
Of course, corporations of any size can monkey around within GAAP; its rules can't stop a company from things such as channel stuffing, shifting operating expenses around, or playing numbers games within various subsidiaries. But it does prevent companies from making its numbers be "whatever they want them to be" (in the old accountant's joke), and GAAP provides at least a measure of protection to investors, be they large mutual funds moving millions of shares or individuals trying to build a modest future.
Yet non-GAAP is coming back. Look at the reporting being done for the most recent quarter. Many companies are reporting "non-GAAP" numbers right alongside GAAP numbers. They're not defining these non-GAAP numbers. Ask them about it, and they provide what sound like credible reasons (mostly having to do with cash flow). No one has yet resorted to "pro-forma" reporting. But the genie is trying to escape from the bottle again.
If you're in business, fulminate against GAAP all you want. Work to get unhelpful rules changed. But although a decidedly unglamorous topic, it was non-GAAP reporting that played one of the major roles in the build-up and then destruction of $7 trillion in NASDAQ company wealth. Let's not be condemned to repeat this lesson of history, OK?
About Roger StrukhoffRoger Strukhoff earned a BA with honors from Knox College, a Certificate in Technical Communications from UC-Berkeley, and an MBA from CSU-East Bay. His work recently won a "Stevie" American Business Award as best publication in its category. His volunteer work in international affairs merited a Letter of Commendation from the Commandant of the U.S. Coast Guard. He splits most of his time between Silicon Valley and Southeast Asia, but can also be found at www.twitter.com/strukhoff
Reader Feedback: Page 1 of 1
#2 |
JDJ News Desk commented on 31 Jul 2005
What's This With Non-GAAP Numbers? Revenues and earnings have been generaly strong, even spectacular, in the most recent quarters for technology companies. With interest rates remaining low, technology purchased in the late 90s bubble at or past the end of its replacement cycle, and innovation continuing to march forward, times should be getting better. So what's this with the funny accounting?
|
#1 |
Web Services Journal News Desk commented on 31 Jul 2005
What's This With Non-GAAP Numbers? Revenues and earnings have been generaly strong, even spectacular, in the most recent quarters for technology companies. With interest rates remaining low, technology purchased in the late 90s bubble at or past the end of its replacement cycle, and innovation continuing to march forward, times should be getting better. So what's this with the funny accounting?
|
Subscribe to the World's Most Powerful Newsletters
|
Today's Top Reads  | |  | By Cloud News Desk Reads: 995 |  | By Yeshim Deniz Reads: 924 |  | By Maureen O'Gara Reads: 855 |  | By Lori MacVittie Reads: 759 |  | |  | By Liz McMillan Reads: 631 |  | By Carmen Gonzalez Reads: 607 |  | By Maureen O'Gara Reads: 600 |  | By Roger Strukhoff Reads: 599 |
Hot Discussions of The Week | By Gwen Morton; Ted Alford | | | | | | | | |
 | By Maureen O'Gara Likewise, which authenticates Linux, Unix and Mac users with Microsoft Active Directory, has started... Nov. 6, 2009 05:45 PM EST Reads: 238 | By Maureen O'Gara The new widgetry features multi-cluster support and enhanced concurrency management to improve scali... Nov. 6, 2009 05:30 PM EST Reads: 333 | By Keith Bergelt In the wake of the financial crisis and its attendant repercussions across the global economy, the U... Nov. 6, 2009 05:15 PM EST Reads: 203 | By Maureen O'Gara It says Traffic Server enables the session management, authentication, configuration management, loa... Nov. 6, 2009 05:00 PM EST Reads: 379 | By Maureen O'Gara The company says “extensive collaboration with large enterprise beta customers, such as Comviva, Hos... Nov. 6, 2009 05:00 PM EST Reads: 298 | By Maureen O'Gara It claims the widgetry, which lets Mac users run Windows and Linux alongside Mac OS X, is faster, sm... Nov. 6, 2009 04:00 PM EST Reads: 584 | By Maureen O'Gara Cisco CEO John Chambers, who has turned into something of an economic oracle probably because he is ... Nov. 6, 2009 03:45 PM EST Reads: 254 | By Maureen O'Gara Microsoft’s browser rivals aren’t satisfied with the tentative “ballot screen” settlement that the c... Nov. 6, 2009 02:45 PM EST Reads: 238 | By Jennifer Rung Do you have digital camera? Do you record special events around you? Publish them on your website wi... Nov. 6, 2009 02:45 PM EST Reads: 242 | By Maureen O'Gara According to Aster Data, applications need to go to “Big Data,” not the other way around. And to do ... Nov. 6, 2009 02:20 PM EST Reads: 317 | By John Savageau The Cloud Computing Conference and Expo in Santa Clara has come to an end, leaving a fair share of o... Nov. 6, 2009 01:45 PM EST Reads: 438 | By Greg Ness As virtualization entered the data center it became an accidental standard bearer for network automa... Nov. 6, 2009 01:30 PM EST Reads: 300 | By Pat Romanski In iPhone Tips, Tricks & Apps for Business Executives, the analyst shares quick and easy ways to tru... Nov. 6, 2009 01:00 PM EST Reads: 236 | By Liz McMillan Investors who are serious about maximizing returns and minimizing risks will find McWilliams' ongoin... Nov. 6, 2009 12:30 PM EST Reads: 347 | By Ellen Rubin The talk at the Cloud Computing Expo this week in Santa Clara was all about enterprise cloud adoptio... Nov. 6, 2009 12:00 PM EST Reads: 420 | By John Cowan RASS and 6fusion USA, Inc. announced a partnership to co-deliver cloud hosted desktop and server app... Nov. 6, 2009 11:45 AM EST Reads: 375 | By Kevin Benedict I can't let this experience go undocumented. I am sitting in Starbucks drinking a Mocha, writing a b... Nov. 6, 2009 11:00 AM EST Reads: 256 | By Carmen Gonzalez The first "Ulitzer New Media Power Panel" took place today at the Santa Clara Convention Center in S... Nov. 5, 2009 07:45 PM EST Reads: 428 | By Yeshim Deniz A majority of executives polled by Deloitte (60.9 percent) believe cloud computing will be a transfo... Nov. 5, 2009 04:15 PM EST Reads: 464 | By Maureen O'Gara Google Thursday open sourced its Closure JavaScript tools – a compiler, a cross-browser, server-agno... Nov. 5, 2009 04:00 PM EST Reads: 600 |
|