Digital Edition

SYS-CON.TV
IBM Under Antitrust Investigation
Has IBM abused its mainframe monopoly?

Gee and it was only four o’clock yesterday morning Microsoft time that Microsoft’s general counsel Brad Smith remarked that antitrust regulators might try targeting somebody else besides Microsoft for a change.

Like, oh, say, maybe, IBM for its $5 trillion 100% mainframe monopoly ­ and here we are just hours later and the New York Times, followed by simply everybody, darling, is reporting that the Obama Justice Department has opened a preliminary investigation ­ complete with subpoenas ­ into charges that IBM has abused its mainframe monopoly ­ the one that IBM swore back in 1997-2001 it would never abuse again so it could get out from under its 1956 consent decree with the US government.

IBM did Microsoft an immeasurable amount of dirt helping to keep the European Commission’s antitrust complaints against Microsoft alive, which explains why Microsoft has been fanning this particular spark.

Anyway, besides telling the regulators it would always license its mainframe widgetry on reasonable and non- discriminatory terms, IBM also basically told the government that non-IBM mainframe gear would eventually replace mainframes, but it has acted ever since 2001 to stomp out any non-IBM rival ­ like mainframe- to-Itanium player Platform Solutions Inc (PSI), which IBM bought last year to shut it up; mainframe reseller T3 Technologies (T3T), which it crushed; and the Hercules open source project that promises to let IBM mainframe operating systems run on x86 platforms, an outfit now trying against all odds to go commercial.

The Times says the DOJ is seeking information from IBM’s mainframe competitors, which may be kinda hard since there’s nobody left.

The DOJ is responding to a “lock-in” complaint ­ by way of a white paper ­ submitted by the Computer and Communications Industry Association (CCIA), a trade organization whose members include Microsoft and Oracle, which means to buy Sun to poke IBM in the eye.

Among other things CCIA accuses IBM of price gouging, exclusionary behavior, tying its operating system to hardware, driving two dozen companies out of business and moving into adjacent Internet markets, the kind of stuff that would send normal folk to jail for a hundred years.

T3T filed a similar complaint against IBM with the European Commission and a private antitrust suit against IBM in New York but last week the New York case was thrown out on the judicial contention that T3T was the wrong company to file suit (lack of antitrust standing in legal parlance) because it was piggybacking on a PSI suit that IBM put out of commission when it bought the thing.

The court said T3T wasn’t a direct target of IBM’s alleged monopolization; and indirect injury is a Gordian knot of distant relationships for antitrust law ­ at least in New York ­ which likes its injuries clear and direct, with the blood all over its carpet.

T3T said it would appeal.

IBM gets an estimated 25% of its revenues from mainframes, which continue to hold an incredible amount of the world’s data.

Would-be rivals complain that IBM refuses to license its mainframe operating systems which it’s pledged to do. CCIA claims that’s an “abuse of intellectual property” although district court Judge Lewis Kaplan found last week in the T3T case that IBM’s refusal to license “does not constitute anticompetitive conduct.” Oh, dear, another conundrum.

About Maureen O'Gara
Maureen O'Gara the most read technology reporter for the past 20 years, is the Cloud Computing and Virtualization News Desk editor of SYS-CON Media. She is the publisher of famous "Billygrams" and the editor-in-chief of "Client/Server News" for more than a decade. One of the most respected technology reporters in the business, Maureen can be reached by email at maureen(at)sys-con.com or paperboy(at)g2news.com, and by phone at 516 759-7025.

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

Register | Sign-in

Reader Feedback: Page 1 of 1



ADS BY GOOGLE
Subscribe to the World's Most Powerful Newsletters

ADS BY GOOGLE
Delegates will leave Virtualization Expo with a full understanding of the interaction between virtua...
Netbiscuits, a leading B2B software service for the creation and operation of mobile websites, annou...
OpenAir, Inc., a NetSuite Inc. company and a provider of cloud computing professional services autom...
“Our continued innovation in imaging software allows us to change the healthcare information distrib...
With their CRM and ERP data systems integrated, Tecan AG's staff and management will benefit from a ...
Until today, Monitis was providing monitoring only for Amazon’s EC2 and S3 services. With the releas...
Solaris 10 10/09 provides new features, fixes and hardware support in an easy-to-install manner, pre...
I've been at this 35 years and I've seen sea changes come and go. If you step back for a moment and ...
There are about 250,000 developers working with Flex and AIR. If you add an army of ActionScript dev...
Optibase announced a new release of its MGW FlashStreamer encoding and streaming platform, introduci...
Rackspace Hosting announced a new service to assist its e-commerce customers this holiday season. Th...
PrismTech is joining forces with Nextel Engineering Systems to deliver much-needed, highly-reliable ...
Microsoft Corp. and eBay Inc. today announced they are partnering to offer eBay Daily Deals through ...
What is a SatNav? I would define it as a small pocket sized computer, with a built-in GPS receiver, ...
Microsoft’s CFO Chris Liddell, 51, a New Zealand import, is bored and wants a better job. So he’s “l...
Cloud computing is a game changer. The cloud is disrupting traditional software and hardware busines...
The newest release of Open-Xchange builds on a consistent theme as its delivers more integration wit...
Recently I installed the Beta 2 version of "Geneva", or ADFS 2.0. All of my machines are now Windows...
Option, the wireless technology company, today announced that its GTM501 will be used in MOTO Develo...
SYS-CON Events (http://events.sys-con.com) announced today that the "show prospectus" for the 5th In...